| Year | Pro Winner | Farm Winner |
|---|---|---|
| 1991 | Washington Capitals |  Rochester Americans |
| 1990 | Buffalo Sabres |  Milwaukee Admirals |
| 1989 | Philadelphia Flyers |  Peoria Rivermen |
| 1988 | Edmonton Oilers |  St. Catharines Saints |
| 1987 | Los Angeles Kings | St. Catharines Saints |
| 1986 | New York Islanders | Adirondack Red Wings |
| 1985 | New York Islanders | Adirondack Red Wings |
Fort Wayne Komets
Hamilton Canucks
Indianapolis Checkers
Kansas City Blades
Manitoba Moose
Moncton Golden Flames
New Haven Nighthawks
Nova Scotia Oilers
Baltimore Skipjacks
Binghamton Whalers
Fredericton Express
Hartford Wolf Pack
Maine Mariners
Philadelphia Phantoms
Providence Bruins
Sherbrooke Canadiens
Springfield Indians